Skip to main content

The Lawyer's Lawyer

Lawyers Helping Lawyers Avoid the Perils of Professional Discipline

Ethical "Info Wars"

Q. After his client denied any text messages about this case, defense counsel sent me a thumb drive with hundreds of them, including some attorney-client communications. May I use these?

A. Even at war with the other side, there are ethical rules of engagement.

Before you make any use of these records, you must notify opposing counsel on the nature and extent of information received. The Rules of Professional Conduct require that lawyers promptly notify the sender of any data which they know or have reason to believe was "inadvertently sent."

Although many of these texts may fall within the scope of discovery, it would appear that some privileged material was mistakenly included. It may be tempting to capitalize on your adversary's error, but your duty to your client does not entitle you to disregard entirely the rights of others.

In law as in life, errors do occur. With the hasty click of a mouse, emails are occasionally misaddressed, privileged messages may be inadvertently produced, or documents may be accidentally included with information that was intentionally transmitted. If you think you received more than your opponent intended to send, you are ethically obliged to inform opposing counsel so that protective measures may be taken.

To preserve the rights of others, this notice requirement gives senders the opportunity to correct these mistakes. But it does not require that you bow to these efforts, destroy what you received or refrain from using the information. If a motion is filed, the court will ultimately decide whether privileges apply, whether privileges were waived by inadvertent production, or whether you must disgorge some or all of the material received. Naturally, if the sender neglects the privilege and makes no effort to limit your use of this information, later objections are less likely to prevail.

Depending on the circumstances surrounding an inadvertent production, you may volunteer to return documents or to delete electronically stored information unread. But without a court order to the contrary, your decision rests with your exercise of "professional judgment." Rule 4.4 comment [3].

When there are no rules, we might apply some variation of the Golden Rule to such dilemmas: "Produce unto others what you would have them produce unto you."

Courting Public Opinion
Ethics on Vacation

Related Posts

Attorney Grievance defense attorney specializes in defending lawyers in disciplinary proceedings before the Maryland Attorney Grievance Commission and the D.C. Bar's Board on Professional Responsibility involving professional misconduct, legal ethics, disbarment, suspensions of law licenses, petitions for disciplinary action, reprimands and sanctions for unethical conduct. If you receive a letter from Bar Counsel Lydia Lawless, Disciplinary Counsel Hamilton Fox, or from any attorney disciplinary board in Maryland or the District of Columbia, retain experienced attorneys with expertise in lawyer discipline and breach of ethics cases to avoid sanctions for professional misconduct. We help lawyers avoid disbarment, suspension, reprimands, censure and informal admonitions by drafting responses to client grievances and ethical complaints; representing lawyers in peer reviews, evidentiary hearings, and oral arguments before the BPR and the Court of Appeals; filing petitions to reinstate an attorney's license to practice law; conducting law firm ethical compliance audits; and drafting legal ethics opinions to protect lawyers from ethics charges. In many cases, disciplinary proceedings may be dismissed, dismissed with a warning, or result in a conditional diversion agreement with Bar Counsel to rectify misconduct. Lawyers may need help in managing their law firm attorney escrow IOLTA trust account and complying with attorney trust accounting rules to avoid charges of ethical misconduct. Do not represent yourself in responding to an attorney grievance, law firm client complaint, or other allegation of ethical impropriety. Attorney grievance defense counsel may help you comply with legal ethics rules, avoid sanctions like suspension or disbarment, and avoid future attorney grievances.


By The Lawyer's Lawyers | Kramer & Connolly and Irwin R. Kramer who are responsible for the content of this informational website.   This website is designed for lawyers faced with attorney grievances. As cases do differ, past performance does not guarantee future results.