Skip to main content

The Lawyer's Lawyer

Lawyers Helping Lawyers Avoid the Perils of Professional Discipline

'Tis the Season ...

Q. My tech client had a huge gift basket delivered to me, with an envelope containing first class tickets for a golf trip to Scotland. May I accept these?

A. Don't pack the kilt just yet.

As a token of appreciation, the seasonal gift basket is a nice holiday gesture that won't raise concerns. You may enjoy the edible parts of the basket without fear of repercussions.

The contents of the envelope are harder to swallow. Under Rule 1.8(c) of the Rules of Professional Conduct, an "attorney shall not solicit any substantial gift from a client, including a testamentary gift, or prepare on behalf of a client an instrument giving the attorney or a person related to the attorney any substantial gift unless the attorney or other recipient of the gift is related to the client."

Given your question, I assume that you did not "solicit" the trip to Scotland. You can go, but the comments following Rule 1.8 warn that such a "substantial gift ... may be voidable by the client under the doctrine of undue influence, which treats client gifts as presumptively fraudulent." Rule 1.8 comment [6]. That alone is frightening.

Expensive gifts are particularly dangerous when acceptance would require the drafting of a will or deed of conveyance. Unless your client also happens to be your father or another close relative, accepting real estate, a share of inheritance, cars or other extraordinary "gifts" may place your license in jeopardy. In such situations, the client must consult with independent counsel before you may accept and, even then, it's risky.

The trip to Scotland won't require special drafting or a formal conveyance. But when clients offer substantial gifts, you should still be leery of accepting. This is particularly true if the donor's generosity exceeds his means. What may be a "substantial" gift from a client selling computers out of his garage may be a small token to a client like Bill Gates. Thus, the client's financial means may be considered in determining whether your acceptance would be reasonable.

Even if your client can clearly afford it, there may be sound reasons to politely decline the expression of gratitude. Clients that love you at Christmas may not feel the same way a few months later. They may even feel entitled to corresponding generosity in the next billing cycle. And the last thing you need is for a client to change her tune and later accuse you of undue influence or other improper motives in extracting that luxury vacation. If that happens, will you be able to overcome the ominous presumption articulated in the comment to Rule 1.8?

Situations differ. But when you go beyond "tokens" of appreciation, more substantial gifts raise more significant ethical concerns. (You may also have to declare your trip as taxable income.) Thus, when it comes to client gifts, it may be better to give than to receive.

A Long Wait to Reinstate
Do Lawyer Lives Matter?

Related Posts

 
Attorney Grievance defense attorney specializes in defending lawyers in disciplinary proceedings before the Maryland Attorney Grievance Commission and the D.C. Bar's Board on Professional Responsibility involving professional misconduct, legal ethics, disbarment, suspensions of law licenses, petitions for disciplinary action, reprimands and sanctions for unethical conduct. If you receive a letter from Bar Counsel Lydia Lawless, Disciplinary Counsel Hamilton Fox, or from any attorney disciplinary board in Maryland or the District of Columbia, retain experienced attorneys with expertise in lawyer discipline and breach of ethics cases to avoid sanctions for professional misconduct. We help lawyers avoid disbarment, suspension, reprimands, censure and informal admonitions by drafting responses to client grievances and ethical complaints; representing lawyers in peer reviews, evidentiary hearings, and oral arguments before the BPR and the Court of Appeals; filing petitions to reinstate an attorney's license to practice law; conducting law firm ethical compliance audits; and drafting legal ethics opinions to protect lawyers from ethics charges. In many cases, disciplinary proceedings may be dismissed, dismissed with a warning, or result in a conditional diversion agreement with Bar Counsel to rectify misconduct. Lawyers may need help in managing their law firm attorney escrow IOLTA trust account and complying with attorney trust accounting rules to avoid charges of ethical misconduct. Do not represent yourself in responding to an attorney grievance, law firm client complaint, or other allegation of ethical impropriety. Attorney grievance defense counsel may help you comply with legal ethics rules, avoid sanctions like suspension or disbarment, and avoid future attorney grievances.

410.581.0070

By The Lawyer's Lawyers | Kramer & Connolly and Irwin R. Kramer who are responsible for the content of this informational website.   This website is designed for lawyers faced with attorney grievances. As cases do differ, past performance does not guarantee future results.
 

NOT AFFILIATED WITH THE ATTORNEY GRIEVANCE COMMISSION OF MARYLAND
OR THE BOARD ON PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY OF THE D.C. BAR